Subscribe to our Mailing List

Get the news right in your inbox!

Mr Potato Head Pumpkin

Mr Potato Head Pumpkin – Pirate Fun

October 25, 2011 Sarah Coggins
This post may contain affiliate links that help support this site at no additional cost to you.

Last year after Halloween, I found a Mr Potato Head Pumpkin Kit in the clearance section at our grocery store. I thought my son might enjoy it this year (and hopefully future years too) so I tossed it into the cart. Fast forward to late September when I bought him a pumpkin from the craft store to decorate. Knowing my toddler, I knew he would want to pull the pieces in and out to play with it so I went with a fake pumpkin instead of a real one.

Mr Potato Head Pumpkin: Supplies

During a naptime, I prepped the pumpkin using my scrapbooking and stamping supplies to help. I dipped the prong from each piece into a black stamp pad so when I determined it’s position, I could press it to the pumpkin and have an instant mark. Then used my paper piercing tool to poke holes in the pumpkin. The holes were just large enough to help me press the pieces in and make perfect fitting holes.

The completed pumpkin …

Mr Potato Head Pumpkin

I pulled out the pieces out (except for the hat and shoes) before he woke up. When he came downstairs and saw the pumpkin and pieces, he was so excited and began playing with it immediately.

Mr Potato Head Pumpkin: Play

Since then, he’s made a number of interesting creations. The hat and shoes are typically in their “correct” spot (I think mainly due to the fact those each have 2 prongs where the other pieces only have 1 each) but all the other pieces vary. I love seeing what he comes up with and have a feeling that our pirate Mr Potato Head Pumpkin will be a part of our Halloween tradition for many years.


  • Jo October 25, 2011 at 8:02 am
    That's awesome! What a neat and pretty inexpensive way to be creative. TFS!
  • Bonnie October 25, 2011 at 8:46 am
    How fun!
  • ter@waaoms October 26, 2011 at 2:13 pm
    I think you were smart to use a plastic pumpkin, then he can enjoy it for a long time!
  • Leave a Reply

    I accept the Privacy Policy

    About Me


    Hi! I'm a DIY and craft obsessed mom to 2. I have my hands covered in sawdust or paint any given day. My husband and kids join me in many of our projects. When we aren't creating at home, we're creating memories in our many adventures. Join along! Read More


    Subscribe & Follow

    Subscribe to our Mailing List

    Get the news right in your inbox!

    DIY Project Money (aka Affiliates)

    At Home


    I highly recommend the book What Was Lost: A Christian Journey through Miscarriage for any woman of faith who has suffered a miscarriage or anyone wanting to gain insight to help comfort a spouse, friend, sister, daughter, etc.


    Fine Print

    2paws Designs is a for-profit site. I make a small compensation from select links when purchases made via one of the affiliate companies. Select posts are sponsored and noted as such. All opinions within this website are my own. Find the Privacy Policy here.

    Amazon Associates Disclosure

    Sarah Coggins is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to

    Hosting with SiteGround

    Twitter Feed